I read a guest essay in Newsday today (November 18, 2026) titled “A better way to choose presidents is in reach.” The essay celebrated the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC)… an initiative started in 2006 by John R. Koza and Barry Fadem and conceived by Constitutional law professors Akhil Reed Amar and Vikram Amar in 2001. The way the compact works is that a state will cast all its electoral votes for the candidate who wins the popular vote notwithstanding that the voters in the state may have voted in the majority for the other candidate.
As of this writing, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, 18 states and Washington D.C. have adopted the compact. Together they control 222 electoral votes. Another 48 electoral votes are needed to reach the 270 threshold that would theoretically allow the compact to take effect.
Interestingly, the author of the Newsday essay failed to mention that Akhil Aram has since expressed reservations about the initiative to which he gave birth. Not the least of the issues he has identified as problematic is that only so called “blue states” have signed on to the compact calling into question the validity of a system that is not supported on a bipartisan basis. He has also cited a lack of uniform voting and vote counting rules among states, potential problems with recounts insofar as the states that did not sign onto the compact might refuse to participate in a recount, and the lack of an agreed upon process to resolve disputes… which he portends will likely lead to a national electoral crisis.
Apart from the issues Aram has raised, and even if they could be resolved, I fundamentally disagree with the premise that the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) is a better or more democratic way to choose the President.
The fact is that in the last 17 presidential election cycles ( a 64 year period) there were only two times the candidate who won the popular vote did not win the electoral vote. Stated another way 90% of the time the person who was elected won both the popular and electoral vote. In those two instances where that was not the case the electoral vote effectively provided a rural and suburban counterweight to the outsized influence of large urban population centers. In other words it worked the way it was designed. So in essence the NPVIC is a solution to a non problem.
Those who support the NPVIC opine that it better reflects the wishes of the overall electorate and adheres more closely to the “one person, one vote” principle. It is worth noting that, rather than referencing the idea of a direct national popular vote, the principle when it was established by the Supreme Court in Wesberry v Sanders (1964) actually dealt with equalizing the number of individuals that would determine the apportionment of House Representatives. Since the number of electoral votes in a state is now, in adherence to the principle, equal to the number of its congressional representatives who in turn represent about 780,000 in total population, the “one person one vote” argument is specious and disingenuous.
Supporters of the NPVIC also view the Electoral College as anachronistic… a vestige of the past which has outlived its usefulness being partially born out of the then South’s efforts to exert undue influence on elections by counting three-fifths of persons who were slaves in the electoral vote count even though they did not have a right to directly vote for any candidate…one way to insure that the institution of slavery would continue. But that was then and this is now. Since that time all citizens age 18 or over are eligible to vote in presidential elections.
So regardless of its origins, the College needs to be evaluated today in terms of the current political environment …and as indicated previously it seems to be working fairly well.
In contrast to what its supporters say, what the NPVIC does (and is completely ignored or downplayed by its supporters) is disenfranchise the majority of voters in a state where the collective electorate did not vote for the person who won the national popular vote by giving that person all the state’s electoral votes. It essentially obfuscates the voting preference differences between and within states while offering an appearance of unanimity. It also ignores that we are a constitutional republic, not a pure democracy, designed to balance the interests of the individual and the state.
The NPVIC is also an end run around the Constitution which would normally require an amendment in order to elect the President by popular vote. It does this by exploiting a loophole in the Constitution (Article II, Section 1, Clause 2) which says: “Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors…”
While this clause effectively allows each individual state to change how it casts its electoral votes it does not expressly allow the states to arbitrarily combine their votes in a way to achieve a “preferred” result.
If any changes are to be made to the electoral process it should bolster the effect each individual vote has on election results…not neutralize, or better yet, steal an individual’s vote.
I propose that a better way to reflect the wishes of the electorate and truly give everyone a voice in alignment with their common interests, while still adhering to the structure of the Electoral College as set forth in the Constitution, is to award electoral votes based on the vote in each congressional district. This as opposed to the statewide winner take-all approach that prevails in all but two states…Maine and Nebraska… and which only requires a plurality of votes in favor of one candidate over the other. In an election as consequential as the one for President, it should take more than a simple majority to throw all votes to one or the other candidate.
A district-based approach makes particular sense in the case of large states where rural areas have nothing in common with dominant urban centers and more in common with rural areas in another state. A district-based allocation of electoral votes allows you to bridge state borders and count every vote as cast versus allowing some states to co-opt the votes of others and arbitrarily transfer votes from one candidate to another. I believe it would actually boost voter participation particularly in states where one party is dominant and where voters who vote for the other party view their vote as having no consequence.
The preamble to the Constitution speaks of forming a more perfect union, not simply creating a national majority-rule democracy. In that regard it was not designed to merely count votes but to structure political power so that competing interests could coexist without one becoming dominant.
In conclusion, the NPVIC is not a better, nor the best, way to elect a president but it certainly is a way for political parties to consolidate power… and not in a democratic way.
Remember what Benjamin Franklin said to the woman who queried him upon learning the Constitution had been adopted: “What have you given us?” Franklin’s answer? “ A republic if you can keep it.”
We would do well to heed his words.